Last night I went to attempt to catch another cat. There are a ton of black cats at the school and I was thinking I'd get one of them this time, but after 45 minutes of waiting, no luck. I decided to try my luck again in the area where the little orange ones hang out and before you know it, I had another one. I checked the ear to make sure it wasn't the same kitty as last week, which it wasn't, so I took it home to the garage. It's a sibling of the one from last week. They all look the same!
This morning I took it off to the SPCA to get fixed. Thankfully there are programs that spay/neuter feral cats for free. I'll head back there later today to pick it up, and I'll find out if it's a boy or girl. Hopefully it's a boy so I can release him sooner. I hate to keep them in the cage for very long.